Corporate Tax Residency for Startups With Overseas Directors: How Central Management and Control Determines Where Your Company Is Actually Taxed

Founders tend to assume a company is taxed where it is registered. An Australian-incorporated company is an Australian tax resident under domestic law wherever its directors are, but a foreign-incorporated company can be one too, and the test depends on where its most important decisions are actually made. For a startup with a Delaware parent run from Sydney, a UK subsidiary whose board is the Australian founders, or a co-founder who has moved to London, tax residency can be in a different place from the one on the certificate of incorporation, or in two places at once.

The Statutory Test

The definition of “resident” in section 6(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) gives three ways for a company to be an Australian resident:

  1. it is incorporated in Australia; or
  2. it is not incorporated in Australia, but carries on business in Australia and has its central management and control (CM&C) in Australia; or
  3. it is not incorporated in Australia, but carries on business in Australia and its voting power is controlled by shareholders who are Australian residents.

A resident company is generally taxed on its worldwide income, and a non-resident only on Australian-sourced income, subject to any tax treaty.

What Central Management and Control Means

CM&C is about high-level decision-making: setting strategy and general policy, deciding what kind of business the company will carry on, approving major transactions and financing. Day-to-day operational management is not ordinarily CM&C.

The leading case is Bywater Investments Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2016] HCA 45. The companies were incorporated overseas and had overseas directors who held board meetings outside Australia. The High Court held they were Australian residents because the real decisions were made by a Sydney accountant, and the directors did no more than implement his decisions without exercising any independent judgment. The location of CM&C is a question of fact and substance.

Directors are entitled to take advice, and a subsidiary’s board is entitled to pay attention to what its parent wants. The line is crossed when the board stops deciding for itself and someone else’s decisions are simply recorded as the board’s.

The ATO’s View After Bywater

The ATO’s position is in Taxation Ruling TR 2018/5 and Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2018/9. Three points matter for startups.

CM&C in Australia is treated as carrying on business in Australia. Relying on Malayan Shipping Co Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1946) 71 CLR 156, the ATO’s view is that if a company carries on business anywhere and has its CM&C in Australia, it carries on business in Australia, even if all of its trading takes place offshore.

CM&C can be in more than one place. In the ATO’s view it is enough that CM&C is exercised in Australia to a substantial degree, so a board split between Sydney and Singapore can produce Australian residency.

Decisions are made where the directors are. In the ATO’s view, a director who dials into a board meeting from Melbourne is participating in that decision from Australia. One director occasionally joining from Australia will not by itself make the company resident, but regular participation from Australia by a substantial part of the board can. Flying to another country for a meeting to approve decisions that have already been made in Australia does not move CM&C offshore. PCG 2018/9 treats artificial or contrived arrangements as a sign of high risk.

In the 2020–21 Budget the then government announced it would amend the test so that a foreign-incorporated company would be resident only if it had a “significant economic connection to Australia”, meaning both its core commercial activities and its CM&C are in Australia. At the time of writing that change has not been legislated, and the existing test applies.

Three Scenarios Founders Run Into

The flipped parent run from Sydney. After a Delaware flip, the US holding company often has a board made up mostly of founders who live in Australia. If strategy, fundraising and hiring decisions for the group are in substance made in Australia, the US parent is at real risk of being an Australian resident as well as a US taxpayer.

The foreign subsidiary with an Australian board. A startup that sets up a UK or Singapore subsidiary to hire staff or sell locally frequently appoints the Australian founders as its only directors. If they make its high-level decisions from Australia, the subsidiary may be an Australian resident and may have to lodge Australian tax returns.

The Australian company whose directors move overseas. An Australian-incorporated company stays an Australian resident under domestic law wherever its directors live, although a tax treaty can treat it as resident solely in another country. The risk runs the other way: countries such as the United Kingdom, New Zealand and Singapore have their own management-based residency tests, so a founder who relocates and keeps running the company from there may make it a resident of that country too. A proprietary company must also keep at least one director who ordinarily resides in Australia under section 201A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and every director needs a director ID.

Dual Residency and Tax Treaties

When two countries both claim a company as a resident, the relevant tax treaty usually contains a tie-breaker. Older treaties allocate residency to the place of effective management. Under a number of Australia’s treaties as modified by the OECD Multilateral Instrument, the tie-breaker is instead a determination by agreement between the two tax authorities, and until they agree the company may be denied treaty benefits. The Australia–United States treaty has no tie-breaker for companies at all, and a company that both countries treat as a resident may be unable to claim treaty benefits, which matters for a US parent run from Sydney.

Dual residency can have domestic consequences too. A company is a “prescribed dual resident” if a treaty treats it as resident solely in the other country, or if it is foreign-incorporated, resident here only because of CM&C, and also resident in another country where it has CM&C. A prescribed dual resident is excluded from a tax consolidated group and from some other concessions.

Leaving has a cost as well. A foreign-incorporated company that stops being an Australian resident, for example because its CM&C moves offshore, triggers CGT event I1 under section 104-160 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth). A capital gain or loss arises on each of its CGT assets that is not taxable Australian property, worked out by reference to market value at that time, so moving a board offshore to change residency can itself be a taxable step.

Practical Steps

  • Decide where each company should be resident, then match the board to that. Board composition and the directors’ locations are the facts that carry the most weight.
  • Have the board make the decisions. Circulate papers, hold meetings where proposals are debated and can be rejected, and avoid resolutions that ratify what a founder or the parent has already done.
  • Record where decisions are made. Minutes should note where each director was when they took part. PCG 2018/9 describes the evidence the ATO looks for, and contemporaneous records are the most persuasive.
  • Get tax advice in both countries before restructuring. Residency affects treaty access, CGT and eligibility for some Australian tax concessions.

Our startup lawyers in Sydney work with founders’ tax advisers on board composition, governance documents and group structures as part of our business setup and structuring work.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. You should obtain advice specific to your circumstances before acting.

Recent Articles

Corporate Tax Residency for Startups With Overseas Directors: How Central Management and Control Determines Where Your Company Is Actually Taxed

Founders tend to assume a company is taxed where it is registered. An Australian-incorporated company is an Australian tax resident under domestic law wherever its directors are, but a …

R&D Advance and Overseas Findings: How Australian Startups Claim the R&D Tax Offset for Work Done Outside Australia

Australian startups rarely do all of their research and development at home. The developers are in Vietnam, or the test facility is in Germany. Many founders discover only at tax time that the R&D …

Workplace Gender Equality Reporting: When Your Growing Australian Startup Hits the 100-Employee WGEA Threshold and What It Must Lodge

Most startup compliance thresholds are about revenue or assets. This one is about people. Once your company employs 100 or more employees in Australia, it becomes a “relevant employer” …