Variation of Class Rights Under Section 246B: How Australian Startups Create, Change and Convert Share Classes Without Breaching the Corporations Act

Every priced round touches share classes. A Series A creates preference shares, a Series B adds another layer on top, a restructure converts founder shares, and an exit turns everything back into ordinary shares. Each of those steps can be a “variation of class rights” under Part 2F.2 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) — principally sections 246B to 246G — and a variation made the wrong way may be ineffective, or may not take effect when the deal documents assume it does.

What Counts as a Class Right

The Act does not comprehensively define “class” (section 57 says only that shares not divided into classes form a single class). In broad terms, shares carrying the same rights form a class, and the rights “attached to” those shares — dividends, votes, return of capital, liquidation preference, conversion — are class rights. They are normally set out in the constitution or the terms of issue.

Rights that sit only in a shareholders’ agreement are a different thing. A board seat or veto given to a named investor is usually a personal contractual right, not a right attached to a share, and Part 2F.2 may not protect it. The shareholders’ agreement and the constitution need to be drafted together.

The Core Rule: Section 246B

Section 246B has two limbs.

If the constitution sets out a procedure for varying or cancelling class rights, the rights can be varied or cancelled only in accordance with that procedure (section 246B(1)). The procedure itself can be changed only by complying with it, so the general body of shareholders cannot use an ordinary constitutional amendment (a special resolution under section 136) to lower the bar first and then rely on it.

If there is no constitution, or it is silent, the rights can be varied or cancelled only by a special resolution of the company and either:

  • a special resolution passed at a meeting of the holders of that class; or
  • the written consent of members with at least 75% of the votes in the class (section 246B(2)).

A special resolution needs at least 75% of the votes cast by members entitled to vote on it, and the notice of meeting must state the intention to propose it as a special resolution and set out its terms (sections 250MA and 249L(1)(c)). The two class-approval routes are not equivalent: at a class meeting the threshold is 75% of votes cast, while written consent requires 75% of all votes in the class.

Either way, the company must give written notice of the variation to the members of the class within 7 days after it is made (section 246B(3)). Failure is a strict liability offence by the company (section 246B(4)).

Most venture-backed constitutions contain their own procedure, typically consent by a stated majority of the class. Read it before relying on the statutory default.

Deemed Variations: Section 246C

At general law, courts have generally read “variation” narrowly: making a class’s rights less valuable is not a variation if the legal rights themselves are untouched. Section 246C overrides that in specific situations:

  1. Splitting a class. If shares in a class are divided into further classes with different rights, that is taken to vary the rights of every share in the original class (section 246C(1)).
  2. Varying some shares only. If the rights of some shares in a class are varied, the rights of every other share in that class are taken to be varied too (section 246C(2)). Converting one founder’s ordinary shares into a new class is therefore a variation for all ordinary holders.
  3. First new class in a single-class company. If a company with one class of shares issues shares with different rights, the issue is taken to vary the rights of the existing shares unless the new rights are provided for in the constitution or in a document lodged with ASIC (section 246C(5)). This is the usual Series A position; the standard fix is to adopt a constitution setting out the preference terms before the shares are issued.
  4. New preference shares ranking equally. Issuing new preference shares that rank equally with existing preference shares is taken to vary the existing preference rights, unless the issue is authorised by the terms of issue of the existing shares or by the constitution as in force when they were issued (section 246C(6)). A later round ranking alongside the Series A can therefore need Series A class approval.

Section 246C does not expressly deem the issue of a new class ranking ahead of existing preference shares to be a variation. Investors usually negotiate an express consent right over senior issues rather than relying on the Act (see our guide to liquidation preferences).

Creating Preference Shares: Section 254A

A company can issue preference shares only if the rights attached to them on five matters are set out in the constitution or have been approved by special resolution of the company (section 254A(2)): repayment of capital, participation in surplus assets and profits, cumulative and non-cumulative dividends, voting, and priority of payment of capital and dividends in relation to other shares or classes of preference shares. A term sheet and a board resolution are not enough.

Converting Between Classes: Section 254G

Section 254G allows a company to convert ordinary shares into preference shares and vice versa:

  • Converting ordinary shares into preference shares requires the same five matters to be set out in the constitution or approved by special resolution (section 254G(2)).
  • A share that was not a redeemable preference share when issued cannot later be converted into one (section 254G(3)).
  • The Act notes that the class rights provisions apply to a conversion. Where preference shares convert under their own terms of issue, for example automatically on an IPO, the conversion is usually analysed as the existing rights operating as drafted rather than a variation of them. That depends on the conversion mechanics being fully written into the terms from the start.

When the Variation Takes Effect

This is the point most often missed. Under section 246E, a variation takes effect on the date of the resolution or consent (or a later specified date) only if all the members of the class agree.

If agreement is not unanimous, section 246D applies:

  • members with at least 10% of the votes in the class may apply to the Court to have the variation set aside;
  • the application must be made within 1 month after the variation is made;
  • the variation does not take effect until 1 month after it is made, or, if an application is brought, until the application is withdrawn or finally determined; and
  • the Court may set the variation aside if satisfied it would unfairly prejudice the applicants, and must otherwise confirm it.

The same timing applies to a constitutional amendment made to allow class rights to be varied. So a round that depends on a class-rights change approved by 80% of a class may not be able to complete on the day of signing. Companies commonly either obtain unanimous class consent, or make completion conditional on the section 246D period expiring without an application (or any application being withdrawn or dismissed). A dissenting shareholder may also have a separate oppression claim under section 232.

Telling ASIC

A company must lodge a notice in the prescribed form (currently ASIC Form 211) within 14 days after dividing its shares into classes for the first time, or converting shares of one class into another (section 246F(1) and (2)). A new issue of shares must be notified within 28 days (section 254X). Failure to lodge either notice is a strict liability offence.

A proprietary company must also notify ASIC of the resulting changes to its share structure and member register under Part 2C.2 (sections 178A and 178C). A later new class, such as a Series B, is picked up through those notices and the section 254X notice even where section 246F(1) is not triggered.

A Practical Checklist

  • Read the constitution first. If it sets a variation procedure, that procedure governs.
  • Identify every affected class. Apply section 246C before assuming only one class needs to approve.
  • Put the rights in the constitution. Do this before issuing a new class, not after.
  • Aim for unanimous class consent. If you cannot get it, plan for at least a one-month delay.
  • Give notice. Class members within 7 days; ASIC within 14 days of a division or conversion, and 28 days of an issue.

Getting It Right

Class rights problems tend to surface late, in a Series B data room or on an exit, when a missing consent is expensive to repair. If you are creating or changing share classes, our startup lawyers in Sydney can review your constitution and structure the approvals as part of our venture capital and capital raising work.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should obtain advice specific to your circumstances before acting.

Recent Articles

Variation of Class Rights Under Section 246B: How Australian Startups Create, Change and Convert Share Classes Without Breaching the Corporations Act

Every priced round touches share classes. A Series A creates preference shares, a Series B adds another layer on top, a restructure converts founder shares, and an exit turns everything back into …

Good Leaver and Bad Leaver Provisions: How Australian Startup Equity Plans Should Treat Different Founder and Employee Departure Scenarios

Every equity plan works well while people stay. Leaver provisions decide what happens when they don’t: who keeps their shares or options, who loses them, and at what price. Most startup …

Rights Issues and Section 708AA: How Australian Startups Can Raise From Existing Shareholders Without a Disclosure Document

When a priced round is out of reach, the most willing investors are often the ones already on your cap table. A pro rata offer to every existing shareholder — a rights issue — looks like the cleanest …