Good Leaver and Bad Leaver Provisions: How Australian Startup Equity Plans Should Treat Different Founder and Employee Departure Scenarios

Every equity plan works well while people stay. Leaver provisions decide what happens when they don’t: who keeps their shares or options, who loses them, and at what price. Most startup documents use two labels, “good leaver” and “bad leaver”. Two labels are rarely enough for the ways a founder or employee can actually leave, and the gaps tend to surface mid-dispute or mid-round.

What Leaver Provisions Do

Leaver provisions are creatures of contract. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) does not define a good or bad leaver, so the starting point is the drafting in your shareholders’ agreement, constitution, ESOP rules and offer letters. Those documents need to say who is a leaver and when, which category each departure falls into, what happens to vested and unvested equity, and how the equity comes back and at what price. Vesting schedules answer part of that; this article is about the categories.

Sorting the Departure Scenarios

No legal rule says which departures are “good”. The table reflects common Australian market practice, and every line is negotiable.

Scenario Common treatment Drafting point
Death, serious illness or permanent incapacity Good leaver Say who decides incapacity, and on what evidence
Genuine redundancy Good leaver Tie it to the role no longer being required
Termination without cause Good leaver Founders push for it; investors often resist
Resignation Varies: often bad during an initial period, good afterwards Consider an “intermediate leaver” who keeps vested equity only
Dismissal for poor performance Contested Decide it expressly; silence invites a dispute
Serious misconduct, fraud or dishonesty Bad leaver Define the conduct precisely
Breach of restraint, confidentiality or IP obligations Bad leaver, often even if discovered after departure Include a reclassification right, with a time limit

“Cause” has no fixed meaning in Australian law, so define it. Many plans borrow “serious misconduct” from regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). That definition is inclusive, not exhaustive. It covers wilful or deliberate behaviour inconsistent with the continuation of the employment contract, conduct causing serious and imminent risk to health and safety or to the business, and conduct in the course of employment such as theft, fraud, assault and sexual harassment. A plan that borrows it should say whether the list is closed. If the board can elect to treat someone as a good leaver, say so, and say how that discretion is to be exercised.

Two cautions. A Fair Work Commission finding that a dismissal was unfair does not automatically change the leaver category under your equity documents, although it may be relevant evidence depending on how “cause” is defined. And the federal government has released draft legislation that would ban non-compete clauses for employees earning below the high income threshold. If it is enacted, bad leaver triggers tied to employment restraints will need review.

Vested and Unvested, Options and Shares

Unvested equity is usually lost on any departure, sometimes with partial acceleration for good leavers. The real negotiation is over vested equity. Good leavers generally keep it or sell it at fair market value. Bad leavers may have to sell at a discount, or lose it.

The instrument matters. Unvested options lapse under the plan rules, with no transfer of shares. Vested options usually stay exercisable for a limited period, covered in our guide to post-termination exercise windows. Shares are harder, because someone has to acquire them.

Price and the Penalty Question

A typical bad leaver price is the lower of the amount paid for the shares and fair market value. Where the gap is large, the leaver may argue the clause is an unenforceable penalty.

In Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 30, the High Court confirmed that the penalty doctrine is not confined to clauses triggered by breach of contract. In Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28, the majority asked whether the detriment imposed is out of all proportion to the legitimate interests of the party the clause protects. A company has a legitimate interest in equity staying with the people building the business, and a clause that simply prices a voluntary exit may not engage the doctrine at all. But the wider the trigger and the deeper the discount on vested shares, the more room a leaver has to argue, whether as a penalty or as oppression under section 232.

Sensible mitigations: keep bad leaver triggers narrow, discount vested shares instead of taking them for nominal value, and set out an independent valuation process.

The Corporations Act Mechanics

A leaver clause is only as good as the mechanism behind it. If the company acquires the shares, it must follow the buy-back procedure in Part 2J.1. Where the shares are held by an employee or salaried director under an employee share scheme that members approved in general meeting, the company can generally use the employee share scheme buy-back procedure: no shareholder resolution within the 10/12 limit, and an ordinary resolution above it. Otherwise it will usually be a selective buy-back, which needs a special resolution with no votes cast in favour by the leaver or their associates, or the agreement of all ordinary shareholders. Both require lodgement with ASIC. Our guide to share buy-back types has the detail. The alternative is a compulsory transfer to other shareholders or a nominee, backed by a power of attorney.

Directors need one more check. Section 200B restricts a company from giving a benefit in connection with a person’s retirement from a managerial or executive office without member approval, unless an exception applies. In a company that does not prepare a remuneration report, that generally means its directors, including a person who was a director in the previous three years. Under regulation 2D.2.03 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth), automatic or accelerated vesting of share-based payments on retirement is a benefit given in connection with retirement. There are exceptions, including for benefits within a cap based on the person’s base salary, but accelerating a departing founder-director’s equity may need a shareholder resolution.

The Tax Layer

Since 1 July 2022, ceasing employment is no longer a deferred taxing point for interests in a tax-deferred scheme under Division 83A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth). A good leaver who keeps options is not taxed merely because they have left. But if good leaver treatment removes the remaining forfeiture conditions and disposal restrictions, that can itself bring forward the taxing point. Where interests are forfeited, section 83A-310 may treat them as never having been acquired, subject to conditions.

A buy-back or compulsory transfer is a disposal. Where a company buys shares back off-market for less than market value, the tax law can treat the leaver as having received market value, and part of the price may be taxed as a dividend. Have the price mechanism reviewed for tax before the documents are signed.

A Drafting Checklist

  • Use three categories if two don’t fit. An intermediate leaver solves most resignation arguments.
  • Define cause, and deal expressly with performance-based dismissal.
  • Choose the mechanism now: buy-back, transfer or lapse.
  • Keep definitions consistent across the shareholders’ agreement, ESOP rules and employment contracts.
  • Set a valuation process and a deadline for exercising the company’s rights.

Leaver provisions are drafted when everyone is optimistic and tested when they are not. If you are setting up an equity plan or reviewing one before a round, our startup lawyers in Sydney can help, alongside our employment law work for growing companies.

This article is general information only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. You should obtain advice specific to your circumstances before acting.

Recent Articles

Good Leaver and Bad Leaver Provisions: How Australian Startup Equity Plans Should Treat Different Founder and Employee Departure Scenarios

Every equity plan works well while people stay. Leaver provisions decide what happens when they don’t: who keeps their shares or options, who loses them, and at what price. Most startup …

Rights Issues and Section 708AA: How Australian Startups Can Raise From Existing Shareholders Without a Disclosure Document

When a priced round is out of reach, the most willing investors are often the ones already on your cap table. A pro rata offer to every existing shareholder — a rights issue — looks like the cleanest …

Section 249D Shareholder Requisitions: How 5% Members Can Force a General Meeting at Your Australian Startup

Founders tend to assume that the board controls when shareholders meet and what they vote on. Mostly it does. But the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) gives a surprisingly small bloc of shareholders the …